Old Republic Home Warranty Earns a Buyer's Choice Award for Exceptional Claims Handling

Buyers Choice Award 2026

Old Republic Home Warranty received a 2026 Buyer's Choice Award from ConsumerAffairs — a nod to its outstanding performance in claims handling.

The Buyer's Choice Awards recognize brands that consistently exceed customer expectations, based on analysis of verified reviews collected on ConsumerAffairs. Using proprietary technology, ConsumerAffairs uncovers which brands create the strongest emotional connections with their customers, and Old Republic Home Warranty came out on top.

So, what sets Old Republic Home Warranty apart? High customer praise earned the company a Best Claims Handling award.

Here's what real customers had to say:

  • Nicole from Georgia: "I’ve had Old Republic since 2022. It’s easy submitting claims with them either by calling or doing it online. The response time is good. They always come back and take care of the issue if they weren’t able to take care of it the first time."

  • Eric from Washington: "Within 10 days, we had a new fridge that cost more than 4 times what we paid for the home warranty. Old Republic, you kept your word and did a good thing in honoring the contract and taking care of us. Thank you.”

  • Arman from Texas: “Old Republic is very good about handling claims. You don't feel like you're having to fight to get the warranty company to do their job.”

What do these reviews have in common? A consistent theme of smooth, dependable claims handling — exactly the kind of experience that defines a Buyer's Choice Award winner.

"At a time when many consumers feel uncertain about making big financial decisions, reviews play an even bigger role in building confidence," said Zac Carman, CEO of ConsumerAffairs. "The Buyer's Choice Awards recognize the companies that consistently earn that trust through positive, transparent customer experiences."

Whether it's the first interaction or ongoing support, Old Republic Home Warranty delivers service that helps customers feel confident!

Any references to non-Old Republic Home Protection (ORHP) websites are provided solely for convenience, and ORHP disclaims any responsibility with respect thereto. Reference to any specific brand, product, or service does not constitute endorsement by ORHP. ORHP does not receive compensation for providing third-party links. In Texas, ORHP is licensed and regulated by the Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation, P.O. Box 12157, Austin, TX 78711, 800.803.9202, www.tdlr.texas.gov. Home warranties offered under the Old Republic Home Warranty brand are service contracts issued by Old Republic Home Protection Company, Inc. 

Topics